Vineyard Dowitcher ID

by Lanny McDowell on August 2, 2010

Lan 020208 014c sq blk cln120x122

If you want to delve  into the arcane business of confidently recognizing a Long-billed Dowitcher in the midst of short-billeds this time of year, and it’s still early, please go right ahead and let me know when you have a long-billed nailed down.  All the shorebird books take on this subject and, sort of like the fairly recent Gulls book, the more you read, the more confused and uncertain you are likely to become.  Less can be more.  Dump some of the plumage factors and go for structural comparison.  If you are lucky, really lucky, you will have one species beside the other and not a single bird, bill tucked and snoozing.

The reason for bringing this ID quandary (morass) to the fore is that I saw and photographed a dowitcher on July 29th out at the flats inside the opening of Tisbury Great Pond.  Its central tail feathers were rufous toward the tips, where the barring “should” have a white or light buffy color.  Most references do not mention this feature, but Paulson’s Shorebirds of North America does write about the rufous in the tail being an identifier for long-billed.

Well, in this case I do not happen to believe this, because in another shot taken of the same bird, the bill droops a bit in the last third of its length, which feature is mentioned as reliable for picking out a short-billed (versus a straighter bill for long-billed).  Since every set of comparisons for these two species seems to end up in the scrapheap of variability – except for voice, which all the writers embrace as distinctive – the tail feather ground color issue will be at home on the list of “may be a factor, but not reliable taken alone as a single distinguishing mark”.  In my book, anyway.

We all seem to want the elements that will offer us certainty, but like so many other BIG questions, sometimes the more you look, the less you know.  Not really fair, is it?

Check out the tail feather tips and the bill on this West Tisbury dow:

Dowicher showing rufous tipped rectrices


IMG_5389 (2)

Dows are Cool! Lan

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

{ 2 comments }

1

Soo 08.02.10 at 10:28 am

I feel the bird we saw was a Short-billed Dowitcher. If you check in The Shorebird Guide by O’Brien, Crossley and Karlson you will find a couple of pictures of juvenile SB Dowitchers with rufous tipped tail feathers.

2

Lanny 09.19.12 at 1:00 pm

It’s nearly impossible to find well-informed people in this particular subject, but you seem like you know what you’re
talking about! Thanks

Comments on this entry are closed.